On eating meat

When i was leaving Pace Wildenstein on 57th yesterday, i saw a handful of women picketing on the corner of 57th and Park Ave in front of the Korean Consulate General.  They were trying to get people to sign up for a petition to stop dog and cat meat consumption in Korea.  A little research has shown me that demonstrators from the IDA (In Defense of Animals) congregate in front of Korean consulates and embassies across the country every year on the first of the Korean bok days (literally the “hot, dog days of summer”).  Apparently, some Koreans consume more boshintang (dog stew) this time of year to help their bodies fight the summer heat.

I walked closer to the demonstrators to read what their posters said, but i was in a rush to find a bathroom, so all i caught were some images of dogs.  Curiously, though, the lady whose poster i tried to read didn’t approach me or try to get me to sign the petition even though she had been pestering all other passersby.  To tell you the truth, she avoided eye contact with me.  On the way back from the bathroom, i saw a different protestor harassing two Korean (and non-English speaking, it seemed) tourists.  These women didn’t have the guts to confront me (because they would’ve confronted, not asked) about the issue so instead harassed Korean tourists who couldn’t even argue back.  How mature.

I have a couple issues with this protest:

1) If it’s true that these dogs and cats are tortured before being slaughtered for consumption, i really hope that these demonstrators are also against foie gras consumption, or better yet, that they’re vegan;

2) If they’re protesting on the premise that dogs and cats are pets and therefore shouldn’t be consumed, then i ask, what prompted humans to domesticate dogs and cats in the first place?  What makes them different from other animals?  And while we’re on the subject, here’s a question for those informed about animal ethics:  do humans even have a right to domesticate animals?  Might we not be interfering with the natural order of things?

For the sake of full disclosure, yes, i eat meat (though not dog/cat meat).  While i do not approve of animal abuse of any kind, i personally do not feel guilty eating meat as long as the animal from which it came was slaughtered in the least painful way possible, because it’s what nature intended:  animals kill and consume each other.  I find no fault in doing anything that nature permits (or perhaps even encourages) us to do, as long as the action does not infringe on anyone’s inalienable rights.  But it’s the protests that aren’t backed up by a logical argument of ethics that get to me.


Filed under culture, ethics, nature, new york

3 responses to “On eating meat

  1. d

    I got a lot of criticism for not really being against it when someone brought it up around the time of 8th grade and pretty much agree with everything above. I honestly don’t really care for domesticating dogs. With a few rare exceptions, they are just too crazy and immature to keep as pets IMO.

  2. Funny that I was discussing this very issue with my roommate here, and I must say I have to agree with you. The eating-dog culture stems from back when a lot of Korean people had very little to eat. The dog meat was probably the only meat these peasants had access to. Not only that, these dogs weren’t exactly raised as pets. They were treated just like cows and horses: one would make them work like one would treat slaves, and eat them when they were of no further use.

    And yet the ignorant protesters make it seem like the dog-eaters are savages who consume their life companions. They don’t just pick up their poodles and put them in stew. They really don’t. This principle applies the same for other animals. They don’t feel any remorse for eating other animals, because they weren’t raised as pets. Why should eating dog be a savagery, when pork tastes just like human meat?

    Of course, the animal-abuse issue still lingers. That, however, pertains to all domesticated animals, not just dogs raised for consumption. All in all, this protest seems very much irrational to me.

    • n

      The fact that dogs used to be treated just like cattle is a very good point that i forgot to include. And i completely agree with you that domestication is not much different from abuse.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s